As far back as I can remember we have always made oven baked peanut butter and jelly sandwiches with a hint of cinnamon.
It was three of us and we wanted something warm, quick and gooey (when we came home from school). I was always in charge of adding the peanut butter to the bread, my brother was in charge of the jelly, and my sister just loved adding cinnamon before we put are sandwiches together. We had the perfect little system!
That’s why when peanut butter & co contacted me and ask me to revolutionized the PB&J sandwich. I had so many ideals in my head that I wanted to do, but the only on that stuck with me was oven baked peanut butter and jelly! I guess all those childhood memories of eating melting peanut butter, gooey jelly and cinnamon on a toasted sandwich.
Let’s be honest, who has time to grill a peanut butter and jelly sandwich? Baking them is so much easier, and all you have to do is sit and wait for them to be done! Enjoy!
Once your finish making your sandwiches, place them on a baking sheet in a 350 degree preheated oven for 10-15 minutes or until bread is toasted.
**For the adult version** add butter to the out side of the bread wrap them in foil and let them bake for 20-30 minutes. They are even better!
It’s Giveaway Time!!
One lucky reader in the U.S.A will have the chance to win 2 jars peanut butter and jelly (of course)! What is peanut butter without Jelly?!
The rules are pretty simple: Tell me what’s your favorite way to eat peanut butter and jelly?
For a second entry: Follow me on Facebook, Pinterest and Twitter, leave a separate comment for each; letting me know you did so!
Good luck to everyone in the contest! Winner will be chosen at random (random.org) on September, 6 2014, please contact me through email with your info thanks!
*** I just wanted to let you know: All opinions expressed in this review are my own (I was not paid for this review). I really just enjoy Peanut Butter & Co peanut butter, and I love giving you the opportunity to try there peanut butter!!
***Important*** Please contact me within 24 hours of being selected, if not I will half to pick another winner! Good Luck!
****Winner**** Congrats to Jenna Weld
I never tried it baked….looks yummy Thanks.
Check out my new blog post and list your favorite beauty products in the comments.
OMG…I’ve never seen a PB&J look so darn good! Um…i enjoy toasting my PB & J…and don’t judge me..but i wash it down with COKE! lol..
xo,
Lisa
You can’t beat peanut butter and jelly sandwiches – baking them is such a great idea! Love the great system you and your brother and sister had when you were younger
Sounds so delicious with a warm PBJ sandwich. Haha, I like the story about yours and your sibling’s system
Childhood memories when they are best
I like peanut butter and jelly on a bagel.
On oatmeal!
These look amazing and like such a comforting treat! Such a simple and delicious concept
I love it!! I will definitely be trying some cinnamon added to my PB next time – sounds like a wonderful idea!
Leave it to you to come up with how to make PB&J good for grown-ups! We actually make pb&j quesadillas here. I put peanut butter in a tortilla and fold it in half, then heat it up for a few minutes on each side. The kids dip the quesadillas in jelly.
I have never had a baked pb&j sandwich. I usually just eat them cold out of my lunchbox at work. Our kids love pb&j and they would love this interesting take.
I like you on facebook as David Lintz
I follow you on twitter as @1froglegs
I follow you on pinterest at 1froglegs
I like pb and j sandwiches if the bread is toasted.
I would just have to stick with the classic peanut butter and jelly on toast cut in half.
I liked you on facebook!
http://www.facebook.com/shannonbryana
I followed you on pinterest as well!
http://www.pinterest.com/shannonbryana
My my, you are making me drool right now! That’s one hell of a yummy PBJ sandwich, Shundara! AHHHHHH!!!!! I would do the adult version, too! haha!
My copain used to eat his PBJ sandwich with “cheesy’ chips way back then. Haha!
I like to have a grilled peanut butter, jelly and cheese sandwich.
I followed on facebook as Dandi Daffyhill.
I followed on Pinterest as DandiDaffyhill.
I followed on Twitter as @dandidaffyhill.
This sandwich sounds amazing. I never would have though of putting a PB&J in the oven.
Baked PB&J sound amazing, I have made a PB&J on my panini press before and loved that! Seriously there is something so simple and amazing about classic PB&Js, they always hit the spot! I would love to try Peanut Butter & Co variety of flavors! I think the cinnamon raisin would be great!
I always toast my PB&J’s in the toaster oven…so yummy!
I follow you on twitter @TmarieHorn
I follow you on Pinterest tmarie9341 (Tammy Horn)
I follow you on Facebook (Tammy horn)
we love grilled pb&j
Never though of them baked. Interesting idea. I like mine straight out of the jar spread on a graham cracker drizzled with honey.
I like the old fashioned sandwich but I also eat PB&J on Ritz crackers with some cheese.
I liked you on Facebook, and followed you on Twitter and Pinterest. Thanks
I love peanut butter and jelly as cookie with the peanut butter as cookie and jelly of your choice as the thumbnail!
My favorite way to eat peanut butter and jelly is in a wrap!
I liked you on Facebook!
I am following you on Pinterest! http://www.pinterest.com/cricketlady29/
Follow you on Twitter! @aktheartist63
I’ve been experimenting with Peanut Butter & Co.’s “The Heat Is On” for peanut sauces on everything from whole wheat noodles to grilled chicken.
I’ve never tried I baked! I always put it on the panini press and have it grilled. So tasty!
I love making a grilled pb&j!
You cant beat a pb n j on wheat bread! Classic
I love it on grahm crackers
I always add bananas and cinnamon to my PB&J
I follow on Facebook
My favorite? Just a tiny bit of jelly with TONS of peanut butter!
Love pb and j of rice cakes and just on a spoon!!!!
Liked on Facebook Sarah Fulginiti
Liked on Pinterest sfulginiti
Liked on twitter @sfulginiti1
I love it on olive oil rosemary bread. It tastes really good!
Oh, that does sound good! I’ve always liked it rolled up in a tortilla, but I never thought of baking.
I like my PB&J on a toasted bagel
My favorite way to eat pb&j is with very toasted bread, and overflowing with bee’s knees peanut butter.
My favorite way to eat peanut butter & jelly is toasted bread with butter. Thanks
I love my peanut butter and jelly on raisin bread.
I love to eat PB&Js with my hubby’s raspberry freezer jam!
I like pb&j on naan bread
on super toasted crunchy bread that i baked from my breadmaker
I love pb&j as French toast sandwiches
Pb and j on warm pancakes. Yum!
I’ve recently discovered how tasty pb&j is inside of baked oatmeal! YUM! Thanks for the chance to win!
Following you on twitter! @Kelsey_Wolfe7
I like mine toasted with lots of both pb & j
I like to mix them and dip pretzles and crackers in it! Yum yum yum yum